Tolerance design of robot parameters using taguchi method. Orthogonal arrays oa provide a set of well balanced minimum experiments and dr. Loss function, orthogonal expiriments, parameter and tolerance design by philip j. Tolerance design assumes d sg and d pcbs are the parameters that can be changed and d deviation is the response for which its coefficients can be estimated. The final step in taguchis robust design approach is tolerance design. Some research has been published on probabilistic tolerance synthesis and optimization.
Overview taguchi design of experiments background of the taguchi method the taguchi process. Pdf tolerance optimization by modification of taguchis robust. Robust design is a technique that reduces variation in a product by reducing the sensitivity of the design of the product to sources of variation rather than by controlling their sources. The sip approach is illustrated with a classical example of nonlinear tolerance design. Request pdf tolerance design of robot parameters using taguchi method a robotic arm must be able to manipulate objects with high accuracy and repeatability. Combining taguchi method, principal component analysis and fuzzy logic to the tolerance design of a dualpurpose sixbar mechanism fuchen chen1, yihfong tzeng2, menghui hsu1, weiren chen1 1department of mechanical engineering, kun shan university, tainan 710, taiwan, r. Quality loss function and tolerance design a method to quantify savings from improved product and process designs. Pdf comparison of taguchi method and robust design. Taguchi philosophy both quality improvement methods are considered. Once you have collected your data, use analyze taguchi design static to analyze the data. You will learn that taguchi s experimental factors parameter design step identifies and optimizes the design factors.
Better characteristics tolerance design for larger. The systems design to select the design factors and levels experimentation design analysis using anova, response tables, main and interaction effects plot 2step optimisation determining factor optima signal to noise ratio tolerance design application of taylor series. The experimental design was done according to an l9 orthogonal array based on the taguchi method. Robust tolerance design with the integer programming. The process of balancing the cost is called tolerance design. Gateway taguchi method input from the voice of the customer and qfd processes select proper qualityloss function for the design determine customer tolerance values for terms in quality loss function determine cost to business to adjust calculate manufacturing tolerance proceed to tolerance design department of mechanical engineering, the ohio. Genichi taguchi is well known for developing a methodology to improve quality and reduce costs, which, in the united states, is referred to as the taguchi methods. Taguchis approach to achieve a high quality system consists of three stages. Taguchi designs include control factors, which are factors in the process that you can control, and noise factors, which are factors that you cannot control when the product or process. Anyone who intends to get a high level understanding of taguchi design, will find the video useful. Optimal tolerance design by response surface methodology. Finding the balance between manufacturing cost and loss.
Instead of reducing variation in individual components by specifying tighter tolerances, taguchi addresses the issue by careful selection of design parameters called factors, resulting in a more robust design that is capable of withstanding varia. Application of taguchibased design of experiments for. Tolerance design was taguchi s last resort method for improving quality taguchi s concept of quality taguchi equated quality with reducing the variance s2 in the final product didnt believe in using fixed tolerances i. Parameter design optimize the system design so that it improves quality robustness and reduces cost. Taguchi methods, quality loss functions, orthogonal arrays, parameter design, tolerance design, signaltonoise ratios 1. Analysis and interpretation methods for experiments. The applications of taguchis robust parameter and tolerance designs to manufacturing engineering are illustrated through designed experiments. Taguchis quality imperatives quality losses result from poor design signal to noise ratios should be improved expose your system to noises systematically two step process reduce variance first then get on target tolerance design select processes based on total cost manufacturing cost and quality. Regardless of your experience with statistics, the second edition of taguchi techniques for quality engineering, by saturn quality engineer phillip j. Taguchis signaltonoise ratios sn, which are log functions of desired output, serve as objective functions for. This is similar to conventional engineering design.
Taguchi s approach to achieve a high quality system consists of three stages. Loss function, orthogonal experiments, parameter and tolerance design, authorp j ross, year1988 p j ross the economics of reducing variation the design of experiment process. His approach gives a new experimental strategy in which a new developed form of design of experiment is used. Oct 20, 2016 tolerance design aids in determining tighter tolerances around the optimal settings identified during the optimal design. Offline quality control quality loss function signal to noise ratiosn for analysis reduced variability, a measure of quality doe the taguchi approach seminar contents ref. Jun 11, 2008 gateway taguchi method input from the voice of the customer and qfd processes select proper qualityloss function for the design determine customer tolerance values for terms in quality loss function determine cost to business to adjust calculate manufacturing tolerance proceed to tolerance design department of mechanical engineering, the ohio. Importance of tolerance design in six sigma projects. Practical application of taguchi method for optimization of. The result of using parameter design followed by tolerance design is successful products at low cost. Phadke,1989, pages 202205 to estimate the rates of changes. In the present work taguchi s parameter design approach is used to study the effect of. Quality loss function and tolerance design quality engineering. The quality loss function developed by taguchi is most useful to quantify the deviation of quality in the area of packaging design and manufacturing tolerance.
Improved quality results when a higher level of performance is consistently obtained. The three steps of quality by design are system design, parameter design, and tolerance design taguchi, 1986. Robust tolerance synthesis with the design of experiments. Specifications might relate to the acceptable length of a shaft, for example, or the acceptable resistance of a specific resistor in a printed circuit board. Combined robust parameter and tolerance design using orthogonal arrays article pdf available in international journal of advanced manufacturing technology 196. Taguchi sought to improve the quality of manufactured goods, and advocated the notion that quality should correspond to low variance. System design system design involves the development of a system to function under an.
Consequently, he developed a strategy for quality engineering that can be used in both contexts. The comparison of the proposed sip approach, the taguchi method, and the conventional mathematical models in tolerance synthesis is presented. This video is the first of the 3section series on taguchi design. Abstract tolerance design refers to the selection of specifications for individual components using formal optimization. Robust design method, also called the taguchi method, pioneered by dr. The following table displays the l8 2 7 taguchi design orthogonal array. In other words, the taguchi approach is a form of doe with. In the present work taguchis parameter design approach is used to study the effect of. The taguchi method of quality control is an approach to engineering that emphasizes the roles of research. Tolerance design for taguchi dynamic response best viewed.
In general, it is difficult to apply the quality loss function directly to diesel engine system design because it is difficult to quantify the monetary cost during the system design for. To achieve desirable product quality by design, taguchi suggests a threestage process. Taguchi versus dual response versus tolerance analysis presented at 1996 fall technical conference. Offline quality control, parameter design, and the. Robustness is a key strategy for achievinghigh quality low cost products and processes. System design refers to the stage when ideas for a new system are used to decide upon the combinations of factors to obtain a functional and economical design. Genichi taguchi, greatly improves engineering productivity. Taguchi recommended a twostep design process, robust design followed by tolerance design. Taguchis product design approach has 3 steps system design choose the subsystems, mechanisms, form of the prototype develop the basic design. Orthogonal expiriments, parameter and tolerance design by philip j. Design of tolerances impacts quality, cost, and cycle time of a product. Philosophy of taguchi approach and method in design of experiment.
Taguchi seek to design a productprocess which is insensitive or robust to causes of quality problems. The use of taguchi orthogonal array would evidently reduce the number of experiments. The applications of taguchi s robust parameter and tolerance designs to manufacturing engineering are illustrated through designed experiments. With the current development in cad computeraided design software, design engineers can proceed with tolerance design problems without knowing assembly functions in advance.
Ross free pdf d0wnl0ad, audio books, books to read, good books to read. It was this epiphany that led taguchi to his robust design process. The l8 2 7 array requires only 8 runs a fraction of the full factorial design. It implies that all data within those tolerances are equally acceptable. Static design in a static design, the response has a fixed mean that you are trying to optimize while keeping variation to a minimum. The aim of this chapter is to stimulate the engineering community to apply taguchi. The approach is illustrated by a case study dealing with 6dof.
No amount of inspection can put quality back into the product. Taguchi realized that the best opportunity to eliminate variation of the final product quality is during the design of a product and its manufacturing process. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. Taguchi s quality imperatives quality losses result from poor design signal to noise ratios should be improved expose your system to noises systematically two step process reduce variance first then get on target tolerance design select processes based on total cost manufacturing cost and quality.
Practical application of taguchi method for optimization. Dynamic design in a dynamic design, the response is measured at each level of the signal factor. The strategy of experimental design used in the taguchi method is based on orthogonal arrays and fractional factorial, in which not all possible combinations of factors and levels are tested. Pdf combined robust parameter and tolerance design using.
Most literature on deterministic tolerance design has focused on developing exact and heuristic algorithms to minimize manufacturing cost. However, taguchi has introduced several noteworthy new ways of conceptualizing an experiment that are very valuable, especially in product development and industrial engineering, and we will look at two of his main ideas, namely parameter design and tolerance design. Robust design 2 february 2016 introduction to robust design what is it and what does it do. Tolerance design recognizes this development process as the responsibility of the entire team and provides practical solutions that each team member can readily apply. Quality loss function an overview sciencedirect topics. The taguchi method of quality control is an approach to engineering that emphasizes the roles of research and development, product design and product development. Ross, shows you stepbystep how to design effective experiments to reduce variation, improve the quality of products and processes, and slash development time and costs. Quality engineering philosophy targets and loss functions.
You will then study the 3 steps of taguchi s product design approach encompassing system design, parameter design, and tolerance design. Taguchi s system of experimental design and data analysis. The stepbystep details of analytical and experimental tolerance development methods are clearly explained, and as a result, you will be able to develop tolerances more. Methodology system, parameter, tolerance design steps. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Use create taguchi design to create a robust parameter design to identify controllable factors in your process that can minimize response variation and make your product insensitive to changes in noise factors. Design of experiments doe using the taguchi approach. The alternative is that the best product has a measurement which is precisely on target. Ross, shows you stepbystep how to design effective experiments to reduce variation, improve the quality of products and processes, and slash. Pdf this paper defines a method for the optimization of design parameter tolerances.
Professional statisticians have welcomed the goals and improvements brought about by taguchi methods, editorializing. Genichi taguchi and others have suggested that traditional twosided tolerancing is analogous to goal posts in a football game. Genichi taguchi 1980 comparable in importance to statistical process control spc, the deming approach and the japanese concept of tqc unique aspects of the taguchi method. It is useful to estimate the effects of main factors on the process. Taguchi parameter and tolerance design are important tool for robust design. Tolerance design was taguchis last resort method for improving quality taguchis concept of quality taguchi equated quality with reducing the variance s2 in the final product didnt believe in using fixed tolerances i.
Then taguchi s tolerance design experiment is applied to determine the statistical significances of the tolerances on robot accuracy. Thus the marriage of design of experiments with optimization of control parameters to obtain best results is achieved in the taguchi method. The l9 orthogonal array had four columns and nine rows, so it had eight degrees of freedom to manipulate four parameters with three levels as indicated. Taguchi analysis design of experiments free pdf ebook. The highest possible performance is obtained by determining the optimum combination of design factors. Orthogonal array design matrix noise factor tolerance interval noise matrix these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. It is a statically approach where we develop the mathematical models through experimental trial runs to predict the possible output on the basis of the given input data or parameters. If the full factorial design were used, it would have 2 7 128 runs. By consciously considering the noise factors environmental variation during the products usage, manufacturing variation, and component deterioration and the cost of failure in the field the robust design method helps ensure customer satisfaction. Design of experiment is the method, which is used at a very large scale to study the experimentations of industrial processes. You will then study the 3 steps of taguchis product design approach encompassing system design, parameter design, and tolerance design. Clearly, it is the responsibility of the designer to determine the loss 1 1 design 1.
Nov 14, 2010 with the current development in cad computeraided design software, design engineers can proceed with tolerance design problems without knowing assembly functions in advance. However, in this case the tolerance limits must be chosen wisely by meng et al. You will learn that taguchis experimental factors parameter design step identifies and optimizes the design factors. Robust design and taguchi methods rutgers university. The general architecture of the proposed method is.
Tolerance design taguchis quality engineering handbook. The consistency of performance is obtained by making the productprocess insensitive to the influence of the uncontrollable factor. Combining taguchi method, principal component analysis and. In taguchi s approach, the optimum design is determined by using design of experiment principles, and consistency of performance is achieved by carrying. The economics of reducing variation the design of experiment process. Taguchi s product design approach has 3 steps system design choose the subsystems, mechanisms, form of the prototype develop the basic design. It delivers a robust design thats entered at target and is least impacted. In this study, the monte carlo simulation is employed using vsa3dpro software to obtain experimental data, followed by rsm to optimize and analyse computer results. Taguchi advocated using inner and outer array designs to.
640 701 480 358 710 361 994 1510 239 1316 751 1192 1423 727 34 354 949 1280 288 1289 1173 998 227 1343 772 649 487 330 500 708 1246 1284 1394 1145 1339 976 990 200 1476 957 25 1 783 1348 662